How Colorblind Racism Thrives in Cook County’s Criminal Court

Van Cleve_Crook County cover.jpg

Above, Van Cleve and the cover of her 2016 book. Below, The Cook County Department of Corrections, one of the country’s of the largest single site county pre-detention facilities. Next to it sits the Cook County Criminal Court building. | Cook County Sheriff’s Office

County Jail.jpgMonday, June 13, 2016 || By Michael Romain || BOOK REVIEW || UPDATED: 6/14/16

Nicole Gonzales Van Cleve’s Crook County opens with a quotation by the famous African-American intellectual W.E.B. Du Bois, pulled from his canonical 1903 book The Souls of Black Folk.

“Thus grew up a double system of justice, which erred on the white side of undue leniency and the practical immunity of red-handed criminals, and erred on the black side by undue severity, injustice, and lack of discrimination,” the epigraph goes.

“It was not then a question of crime, but rather one of color, that settled a man’s conviction on almost any charge. Thus Negros came to look upon courts as instruments of injustice and oppression, and upon those convicted in them as martyrs and victims.”

The passage serves as both prophecy and pithy history lesson. And if Van Cleve’s numerous unbelievable accounts of blatant racism are to be believed, the passage should be posted outside of the entrance of the Cook County Criminal Court Building at 2650 S. California Avenue in Chicago.

Du Bois’s words should symbolize the kind of reckoning one only hopes is waiting for the next Cook County State’s Attorney when she arrives in that office next year. Van Cleve’s 190-page report is based on over 1,000 hours of observing the day-to-day work of public defenders and prosecutors inside of the largest unified court system in the country.

Van Cleve started her nearly 15-year ethnographic study of the court system in 1997 and supplemented it with 104 “interviews with judges, prosecutors, and public defenders and another 1,000 hours of additional observations from 130 ‘court watchers’ trained in collecting qualitative data in the courthouse,” she writes.

What emerges is a study in 21st Century contrasts. According to Van Cleve’s observations, the mostly poor, African-American and Hispanic subjects who routinely circulate through 26th and California (or simply 26th and Cal) are degraded, shamed, disrespected, mocked and exploited by the mostly white, mostly male legal authorities — from the judges to the prosecutors and public defendants.

And yet, a majority of those very legal professionals, namely the judges and the prosecutors, “described the courts as racially blind and felt that there was no discrimination against poor defendants of color.” That’s when the subject of race, an almost unspoken taboo among 26th and Cal’s legal custodians, is brought up at all.

The dominant demeaning trope within the criminal complex, Van Cleve writes, is the “mope,” which is “shorthand for a person who violates” the values of hard work, competency and self-motivation. Virtually every person of color who comes through 26th and Cal is identified as a “mope,” whether by legal professionals or by guards.

In the eyes of the professionals facilitating this daily degradation ceremony, Van Cleve writes, the color of a mope’s skin is incidental to his or her moral inferiority.

“As their colorblind logic goes, disdain for defendants is based not upon the color of their skin but upon the moral violations they embody,” writes Van Cleve, a criminal justice and legal professor. “Given this rationale, crass, racialized humor outside the scope of colorblind racism is acceptable and not based on ‘race.’”

And that, Van Cleave argues, is how, in part, colorblind racism operates at 26th and Cal. One can only wonder what this means for the wider world. VFP

An excerpt from Crook County: Racism and Injustice in America’s Largest Criminal Court | Stanford Law Books | 2016 | 252 pp.

How to play ‘Niggers by the Pound’ without Being ‘Racist’

“Many of the judges currently on the bench in Cook County started their careers in the prosecutor’s office in the 1980s and 1990s. That generation of prosecutors played a game that had two titles: one that masked the game’s racism and another that flaunted it. The game was ‘The Two-Ton Contest,’ or ‘Niggers by the Pound’ and was described in Steve Bogira’s Courtroom 302. Here is how you play: Look at the weight of the defendant in the case file. Convict the defendant, and then talley the weight as a conquest to earn yourself points for pounds. One strategic tip: Convictions of the heaviest defendants are worth big points in this game, so you must offer them good plea deals, regardless of their crime, to incentivize the conviction of the fattest defendants. Be the first prosecutor to convict four thousand pounds of niggers and you win! (Page 54).

For more local news, ‘Like’ VFP on Facebook

Facebook Like

Take a summer reading challenge

books (1)

Afriware Books, 1701 S. 1st Ave., Suite 503, is challenging residents to read a minimum of 15 minutes a day in June and July. Those who accomplish the feat won’t just gain insight, but they could also win a gift card valued at up to $10. The challenge is limited to participants who are at least 17 years old.

The form to enter the challenge can be downloaded below or by clicking here.

“Studies show that adding culturally specific titles to a child’s education can increase GPA up to two letter grades,” note Afriware’s owners. “Stop in to select your own titles or we can make recommendations. Afriware Books has plenty of books for children and teens to choose from!” VFP

3 thoughts on “How Colorblind Racism Thrives in Cook County’s Criminal Court

  1. That is so untrue. A majority of the officers and cook county department of corrections are African-American officers. In most cases inmates are treated with respect. Until then attacking officer or a judge. Why not report on the hundreds of officers being assaulted every year. Or having urine or feces thrown at them. Why don’t you report on that???

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.